• welcome

    By Anders Drejer & Christer Windelov-Lidzélius

    Why do companies fail? Is it inevitable, caused by disruptive changes in the organisations’ environment or managerial sloppiness? Or can it be avoided? Interestingly, in a world where interest has always mainly been in the winners, we know a great deal about how companies fail. There are different views on what failure actually means and there is not necessarily agreement on how come that a company failed. For instance, not reaching explicit goals or even growing or earning less than the industry average may be perceived, by some, as corporate failure. We will, however, be focussing on the ultimate corporate failure – in which the company ceases to exist as juridical entity.

     

    Fact and fiction about corporate failure

    Beginning with the idea that corporate failure is the ultimate form of failure, bankruptcy, we reviewed 62 publications and models for corporate failure. We will spare you the boring details and sum up the key learnings instead.

    First, it is a myth that corporate failure is the result of laziness on the part of top managers. The sayings “they didn’t want it enough” or “they didn’t try hard enough”, however tempting to utter about failed rivals, are simply not true. Research and experience show that during crises top managers work even harder and longer than their counterparts in other organisations.

    So, then, why do they fail? Well, our second finding is that the hard-working top managers are busy doing the wrong things during a crisis. Consider the well-known example of Blockbuster, which eventually failed as it did not respond in time to the emerging industry of streaming and Netflix. The CEO at the helm, John Antioco, has been very explicit in his (self-)defence of his actions during the company’s demise. Antioco is enraged by claims of inaction and incompetence, and emphasises the immense workload which he and his teams took on, also blaming short-sighted shareholders for demanding that Blockbuster cut investments in digitalisation in favour of short-term results. He may well be correct.

     

    Active inertia

    John Antioco may well be right. The example of Blockbuster and many others follow a pattern known as “Active Inertia” or, in more popular terms, being busy shooting yourself in both feet.

    In order to fail, first you need to be successful. Here, “successful” means that you, as a top manager/management team, create a so-called market picture (your perception of that market) that is in line with the realities of your chosen market. Based on this, you design processes to create value for your customers that they appreciate or even consider unique, and you acquire technologies and assets to support the value creation. Finally, out of the success emerges a set of positive values among your employees that carries the business model. The latter may be labelled corporate culture or the social reinforcement of practices that create success.

     

    After all, the employees meet your customers every day and will be the first to sense that all is not well with the market picture

     

    How do you fail?

    Markets, indeed the world, have a tendency to change. The main reason for failure according to our research has revealed that instead of altering your market picture according to the changed market, you make your market picture a dogma. Something that is repeated more and more loudly but never questioned. For instance, in the newspaper industry there was a dogma for a long time that millennials would “grow up and become like us, the ageing, affluent executives living secure lives in the suburbs”. Alas, that did not happen. In 2020, the average age of buyers of Denmark’s largest newspaper is 63. It will be 64 in 2021. It easy to predict the outcome. But the dogma remains and remains unquestioned. Also, your processes cease to be directed at customers and become routines that are repeated for the sake of the routine, not for the customer. This internal focus has a tendency to create additional routines that do not create value for the customers at all and, additionally, are costly. Still, in this situation, you soldier on with your precious routines. Furthermore, your assets cease to be valuable and become ballast that weighs the company down. So, you own a great many buildings and trucks for distributing packages? How valuable are those assets, if drones emerge to disrupt the industry? Last, and worst, your employees lose faith in the business model and start finding new jobs and/or getting lazy or even destructive. After all, the employees meet your customers every day and will be the first to sense that all is not well with the market picture.

    And what do you do? You make cost-cutting exercises and strategy processes, hire consultants by the numbers and work hard! But if you fail to ask the right questions, you are like a horse stuck in quicksand – the harder you try to get out of your predicament, the deeper into trouble you will get.

     

    Kaospilot Publishing launches a journal aimed at disseminating research, ideas and opinions about innovation and related fields. This piece is out is by Anders Drejer and Christer Windel?v-Lidzélius. It speaks to the fundamental need of renewal and development.

    Also available through Spiro School of Business -The Innovation Series
    Share this...
    • Linkedin

    Related articles

    Think less and do more!

    The Art Of Imperfect Action

    Since graduating

    Meet Dennis Dybdal Founder of WAKA Global

    Since graduating

    Meet Anne Kjaer Bathel Founder of ReDI School

    Since graduating

    Meet Jesper Kjeldsen Founder of Postevand

    Since graduating

    Meet Ida Tin Founder of Clue

    WORKING WITH THE MUNICIPALITY

    Solving COVID Problems

    Since Graduating

    The Netflix of Online Courses on Sustainable Development

    BOOK RELEASE

    The future looks bright, go out there and create it.

    Interview with Henrik K?hler Simonsen

    The Future of Online Learning

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Andreas Broman

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Hans Ohlsson

    INNOVATION STUDIES

    Busy Dying, anyone?

    Innovation studies

    The Innovation Imperative

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Amalie Harris Barfod

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Britt Barfeldt

    GUEST LECTURERS

    Meet Tony Quinn

    Working with Vestas

    Meet Magnus Alexander Haals

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Tue Krabbe-Juelsbo

    Innovation studies

    Send Lawyers, Guns and Money

    SINCE GRADUATING

    Meet Kathrine Overgaard Warberg

    Innovation studies

    Cowboy Number One and His Problems

    Since GRADUATING

    Meet Andreas Lange

    Meet Dinant Roode

    Professional Rebel Facilitating Learning Spaces

    Design for Sustainability

    Meet Frank O?Connor

    Innovation Studies

    Gazza at the Controls

    Extended network of lecturers

    Meet Cesar Alves Ferragi

    Community Building

    Meet Current Student Anthon Khorami

    Innovation Studies

    Why Do We Fail?

    Since Graduating

    Meet Rasmus Stride

    Since Graduating

    Meet Haotian Cheng

    Innovation Studies

    How to Avoid Failure

    Since Graduating

    Meet Nkuli Mlangeni-Berg

    Educator | Learning Experience Designer | Facilitator

    Meet Boris Kelly

    Extended network of lecturers

    Meet Nathan Shedroff

    Since Graduating

    Meet Nikolaj K?ster

    Mindsets that will support you and your organization

    Designing for a Trans- formation Economy

    Since Graduating

    Meet Anders Sj?stedt

    Obituary for Pete Sims

    买跳蛋被快递员发现操

    HoMEԱֲ